How a Services Firm Increased Project Profitability by 42%
A 55-person consulting firm eliminated unprofitable projects and optimized resource allocation using real-time project profitability tracking and predictive budget insights.
Company Overview
A management consulting firm specializing in digital transformation and business process optimization for mid-market and enterprise clients. With 55 consultants, project managers, and analysts, the firm manages 25-30 concurrent client engagements ranging from fixed-price projects to time-and-materials contracts.
- Team Size
- 55 employees
- Annual Revenue
- $12M
- Active Projects
- 25-30
- Location
- Chicago, IL
The Challenge
Invisible Profitability Problems Eroding Margins
- Blind Spots in Project Economics
The firm discovered profitability only after projects ended, often 3-6 months too late. By the time they realized a project was unprofitable, they had already burned through budgets and couldn't recover losses. 30% of projects finished in the red.
- Scope Creep Without Visibility
Fixed-price projects routinely exceeded estimated hours. Clients requested "small changes" that turned into major work. Without real-time tracking, project managers couldn't identify scope creep until budgets were exhausted and margins destroyed.
- Resource Allocation Inefficiencies
Senior consultants (high hourly cost) were assigned to tasks that junior analysts could handle. Without visibility into actual time spent by role and rate, the firm consistently over-allocated expensive resources, crushing project margins.
- Inaccurate Project Estimates
Sales team quoted projects based on guesswork rather than historical data. Without visibility into how long similar projects actually took, estimates were consistently 40-50% under reality, leading to unprofitable contracts and strained client relationships.
The Solution
Real-Time Project Profitability Tracking
The firm implemented WorkComposer to gain real-time visibility into project profitability, resource allocation, and budget burn rates across all 55 consultants and 25-30 active engagements.
- 1. Real-Time Project Profitability Dashboard
- Project managers gained instant visibility into profitability for every active project. The dashboard showed hours consumed vs. budgeted hours, actual cost vs. revenue, and projected margin at completion. Warning alerts triggered when projects approached budget thresholds.
- 2. Automatic Time-to-Project Allocation
- Consultants' time was automatically allocated to specific client projects and tasks. At the end of each day, they reviewed and confirmed allocations in seconds. This eliminated timesheet guesswork and ensured every billable hour was captured and attributed correctly.
- 3. Resource-Rate Optimization Insights
- The system tracked which consultants (by role and rate) worked on which tasks. Analytics revealed that 40% of senior consultant time was spent on tasks suitable for junior analysts, costing the firm $200K annually in margin erosion. Resource allocation was optimized based on these insights.
- 4. Historical Data for Accurate Estimates
- The firm built a library of historical project data showing actual hours by project type, phase, and deliverable. Sales teams used this data to create accurate estimates, reducing estimation errors from 45% to 8% and ensuring profitable contract terms.
Implementation
Strategic Rollout Over Three Weeks
Configured WorkComposer with all active client projects, budget allocations, and billing rates by consultant role. Established project templates for common engagement types. Set up profitability alert thresholds at 75%, 90%, and 100% of budget.
Launched pilot with 3 project teams (15 consultants). Trained on automatic time allocation, project selection, and daily time confirmation. Project managers learned to monitor profitability dashboards and respond to budget alerts.
Rolled out to all 55 employees. Sales team trained on using historical data for project estimates. Leadership gained executive dashboard showing portfolio-wide profitability metrics and resource utilization across all projects.
Within the first month, project managers identified and intervened on 4 projects heading toward losses. Early detection allowed renegotiation of scope, reallocation of resources, and course correction—saving an estimated $150K in potential losses.
Results
Dramatic Profitability Improvement Across Portfolio
- ↑42% Average Project Profitability Increase
- Average project margin improved from 18% to 25.5%. This came from better resource allocation, early intervention on troubled projects, and elimination of scope creep through proactive budget monitoring.
- ↓Unprofitable Projects Dropped 90%
- From 30% of projects finishing unprofitably to just 3%. Real-time profitability visibility allowed project managers to detect and fix problems early, preventing losses before they accumulated.
- $$1.2M Additional Annual Profit
- The 7.5 percentage point margin improvement on $12M in revenue generated an additional $1.2M in annual profit. This came from existing projects becoming more profitable, not from acquiring new clients.
- 📊Estimation Accuracy Improved 82%
- With historical project data, sales team estimation errors dropped from 45% to 8%. Accurate estimates led to profitable contracts, realistic client expectations, and fewer scope disputes.
- ⚡Resource Utilization Optimized by 35%
- By reallocating senior consultants away from junior-level tasks, the firm freed up 35% of senior capacity for high-value strategic work. Junior analysts took on appropriate tasks at lower cost, improving both profitability and team development.
- 🎯Scope Creep Reduced 67%
- Real-time budget visibility allowed project managers to identify and address scope creep immediately. Client conversations about additional scope became data-driven, leading to proper change orders and protected margins.
"We thought we were running a profitable firm, but we were flying blind. WorkComposer showed us that nearly a third of our projects were losing money, and we didn't know until it was too late. Now we can see profitability in real-time and fix problems before they destroy margins. It's like turning on the lights in a dark room—we finally see what's really happening."
Related Solutions
Explore How WorkComposer Can Help Your Business
Project-Based Work
Track project budgets and profitability in real-time with automatic time allocation.
Professional Services
Optimize consulting profitability with resource allocation insights and budget tracking.
Billable Hours Tracking
Capture every billable minute and maximize revenue with accurate time tracking.
Let’s get you started
Start tracking time, monitoring productivity, and generating insights in just minutes. WorkComposer is designed for ease, speed, and real results.
- ✓ Automatic and manual time tracking
- ✓ Real-time productivity reports
- ✓ Web and app usage monitoring
- ✓ Screenshots and attendance tracking
- ✓ Easy team onboarding
No credit card required. Setup takes less than a minute.
